@thelifegivingwatersചാനൽ24w
I replied in detail to a message sent by a viewer who highlighted certain objections. It can be found in the messages below. Sharing it here for the benefit of others.
Praise the Lord! Thank you for watching my video and sharing your views here. As discussed in the video, I do not want to get into a debate, since according to me, theological debates should be done by theologians who understand scriptures and it’s theological, literal and cultural context very well and are more suited to answer these objections. That said let me reply what the Catholic Church teaches on this
1. The saints aren’t “dead” in the way the argument assumes.
Jesus directly addresses this. When questioned about the resurrection, he says of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob — long buried — that God “is not God of the dead, but of the living, for to him all are alive” (Luke 20:38). At the Transfiguration, Moses and Elijah appear and converse with Jesus about his coming death in Jerusalem (Luke 9:30–31). They had died centuries earlier, yet they’re conscious, aware, and engaged with what’s unfolding on earth. So “resting in peace” doesn’t mean unconscious or cut off — in Christ the faithful departed are more alive than we are.
2. Scripture shows heaven is aware of earth, and the saints present our prayers.
In Revelation 5:8 the elders in heaven hold “golden bowls full of incense, which are the prayers of the saints” — heavenly figures actively offering the prayers of God’s people. In Revelation 6:9–10 the martyrs under the altar cry out to God about events still happening on earth. Jesus says there is “joy before the angels of God over one sinner who repents” (Luke 15:10) — heaven knows when a sinner repents. And Hebrews 12:1 calls the saints a “great cloud of witnesses” surrounding us.
3. Asking others to pray for you is biblical — and the saints in heaven are the holiest “others” available.
James 5:16 says “the prayer of a righteous person has great power.” Hebrews 12:23 describes heaven as containing “the spirits of the righteous made perfect.” The Catholic logic is simple: if it’s good to ask a fellow Christian on earth — still a sinner — to pray for you, how much more the righteous already perfected in God’s presence? Asking Mary to pray for you is the same act as texting a friend “please pray for me.” It isn’t praying to her as God.
4. “One mediator” (1 Tim 2:5) — read the whole passage.
That’s the strongest verse against this practice, but look at what surrounds it: just four verses earlier Paul urges “supplications, prayers, intercessions… for all people” (1 Tim 2:1). So in the very same breath that Paul names Christ the one mediator, he commands Christians to intercede for one another. Intercession clearly doesn’t violate Christ’s unique mediation. Christ’s mediation is the one redemptive bridge; all our prayers for each other — on earth or in heaven — work through his, not alongside it as a rival.
5. Mary specifically.
She prophesies her own honor: “all generations will call me blessed” (Luke 1:48). At Cana (John 2:1–11) she intercedes — “they have no wine” — and Jesus, though saying his hour hadn’t come, acts at her request. It’s the first public miracle, prompted by her intercession. And her words there are the whole Catholic posture toward Mary: “Do whatever he tells you.” She always points to Christ, never away from him.
6. On worship and God’s glory — Catholics actually agree with the final line.
This is worth stressing, because it’s the biggest misunderstanding. Catholic teaching reserves worship (adoration) for God alone; honoring Mary and the saints is a different thing entirely, the way you’d honor a hero or a parent (Exodus 20:12). Catholics don’t believe Mary protects by her own power or shares God’s glory — any help comes from God answering her prayers. So “God does not share his glory” isn’t a point against the Catholic view; it’s something Catholics affirm too.
I do agree that this is one of the real, long-standing disagreements between Catholic and many Protestant Christians, and your reasoning is sincerely from Scripture. The Catholic answer isn’t that we’ve ignored the Bible, but that passages like Revelation 5:8, Luke 20:38, and 1 Timothy 2:1 fill out a picture the “soul sleep” reading leaves out.
We are brothers and sisters in Christ sharing similar beliefs but having some major differences. Once again, thank you for for coming here and sharing your views. Several others have also shared similar views, esp those from other denominations and I wanted to reply to all those objections here with details on what the Catholic Church teaches